Review: Neglecting Connection:
Associations Between Parental Emotional Support and Youth Mental Health in Four
Latin American Countries {under peer review}
Reviewer: Dr. Zyed Achour
Completed: 04-10-2026 11:01
Recommendation: Resubmit for Review
|
|
Yes |
No |
N/A |
|
Is the research question clearly defined? |
+ |
||
|
Are the methods appropriate and sufficiently detailed? |
+ |
||
|
Is the data analysis robust and replicable? |
|
+ |
|
|
Are the conclusions supported by the results? |
|
+ |
|
|
Is the manuscript well organised and clearly written? |
+ |
|
|
|
Are tables, figures, and supplementary material informative and necessary? |
+ |
|
|
|
Is the abstract an accurate summary of the study? |
+ |
|
|
|
Does the manuscript contribute meaningfully to the field? |
+ |
|
|
|
Is it relevant to the field of mental health or related disciplines that are connected to the scope of the Journal? |
+ |
|
|
|
Are ethical approvals and participant consents adequately described? |
+ |
|
|
|
Have competing interests, funding, and data availability been transparently declared? |
+ |
|
Comments for the authors:
Thank you for
this opportunity.
The manuscript
addresses an important topic. It uses large nationally representative surveys
in countries that are rarely studied. Measuring the relationship with the
mother and with the father separately is a strength. The results on suicidal
thoughts, self-inflicted injury and suicide attempts are the most consistent.
However, I
believe several corrections are needed to give the paper more impact.
Abstract and
conclusions
1. I notice that the wording shifts from
association to causation. The title refers to associations and the text mostly
uses "associated with". But causal wording also appears in the
abstract (communication difficulties "increased"), in the results
(protective effect, reduced the odds, raised the risk), in the discussion
(protective factor) and in the conclusions, where parental support
"significantly contributes" to youth mental health. Yet the
limitations acknowledge that causal inferences cannot be established. The
wording should be made consistent.
2. The abstract states that, across all four
countries, alcohol abuse consistently showed associations with communication
difficulties and a lack of parental closeness. If I understand correctly,
Tables 7 and 8 do not support this sentence. In Haiti, the authors themselves
write that there were no associations with alcohol abuse, and communication
with parents is not measured there. In Colombia, difficulty talking to mother
or father is not associated with alcohol use, and only the Close category for
closeness with mother stands out. In El Salvador, only two results are
significant, with lower bounds close to 1. Only Honduras shows a clear pattern.
This sentence of the abstract should be revised.
Introduction
3. My impression is that the prevalence figures
for mental health disorders cited for the four countries are not comparable.
They come from four studies published between 2011 and 2023. The authors
themselves describe them as studies of diverse youth populations. Yet writing
that Honduras exhibits the highest prevalence suggests a ranking. Please
specify the population, the age range and the instrument used in each study.
Please also indicate whether these are diagnosed disorders or symptoms.
4. In addition, the alcohol figure is a per
capita consumption for the general population. An indicator specific to youth
would be more appropriate.
5. While reading, I noticed that the central
concept changes name throughout the text. It is parental emotional support in
the title, then parental involvement, parental engagement, and parental
emotional social support in the table titles. I recommend defining it once and
keeping the same term. It would also be useful to explain how the three
variables measured (relationship with mother or father, difficulty talking to
mother or father, closeness with mother or father) correspond to the emotional
support announced in the title.
6. The hypothesis seems too vague to me. It only
states that parental support is associated with psychological distress,
suicidal behavior and substance use, with patterns differing by country. It
does not specify the expected direction, although the theoretical section
suggests one. It also says nothing about mothers and fathers, although the
introduction presents the differential impact of support from mothers versus
fathers as a gap. Family Systems Theory is not used to derive specific
predictions, beyond the idea that the impact likely varies across Latin
American countries. Finally, describing the family as an "integrated
emotional unit" recalls Bowen rather than Minuchin (1974). Please clarify
which tradition the authors follow.
Methods
7. Sex is neither controlled for nor used to
stratify. The models are adjusted for age, highest level of education,
ethnicity and wealth index (ethnicity is not included for El Salvador), and the
distribution of respondents by sex is not shown in Table 1. Yet the authors
report mutual adjustment for all confounding factors available in the survey.
They also refer to gender roles in the introduction and to patriarchal norms in
the discussion. Is this a choice or an omission? It might be useful to add sex
to the models or to present the results separately for females and males.
8. The psychological distress scale should be
named and described in more detail. The text refers to the sum of six variables
without citing an instrument or a reference. Please specify the instrument
used.
9. There seems to be an error in the sample size
for Colombia. The Methods give n = 2,433, the same figure as for El Salvador,
whereas Table 1 gives n = 2,705. Only the second figure matches the stated
total of 13,174. Please correct this.
10. Haiti is difficult to compare with the other
countries. The data were collected in 2012, the sole exposure measured is
closeness with mother and father, and only psychological distress and alcohol
use are available. The authors acknowledge this in the limitations, but the
title and the abstract present Haiti like the other three countries. Its place
should be clarified. The Methods state that information about Haiti is
presented in supplementary material, whereas Table 8 is in the main text.
Likewise, the text mentions adjustment for the wealth index only, whereas the
table note indicates age and wealth index.
Results
11. In Table 1, the percentages do not match the
counts. In El Salvador, for example, 226 cases of self-inflicted injury out of
2,433 give 9.3%, not 11.5%. If the percentages are weighted, please say so.
12. For psychological distress, a score ranging
from 6 to 30, the results are presented as Incidence Rate Ratios and
interpreted as a likelihood or a chance of distress. Yet this is a score, not
an event. In addition, for Honduras, the percentages for mothers and fathers
cited in the text should be checked against Table 2.
Discussion
13. I find that the cultural explanations put
forward in the discussion (familism, patriarchal norms) do not rest on any
variable measured in the study. For example, the discussion presents the
connection with the father as specific to Honduras. Yet in Table 2, the
adjusted estimate for relationship with father is 0.93 in Colombia, 0.93 in El
Salvador and 0.94 in Honduras. Only the confidence interval differs, as
Honduras has a sample about twice as large. If the differences between
countries cannot be formally tested, I suggest presenting these interpretations
as hypotheses.
14. One of the limitations seems to contradict the
Methods. The authors state that the study did not account for family income,
education or violence exposure, whereas the models are adjusted for level of
education and wealth index. Moreover, violence exposure is measured in the
VACS. Please clarify.
15. The data are described in two different ways.
The abstract and the Methods refer to "publicly accessible" VACS
datasets, whereas the Data Availability Statement says the data are "not
publicly available" and that a request must be sent to the CDC. Please
make these two statements consistent.
Finally, I
suggest a complete check of the text against the tables.
With these
revisions, I believe the paper can make a useful contribution to research on
youth mental health in the region.