Global Institute for Mental Health Innovations, Networking and Development
Mental Health Open ISSN 3122-1181 Vol. 2 (2026). Issue 1.
Political Paradox of Happiness: Mental Health Policies are not Self-defeating {under peer review}
conceptual insights & critical reflections
Lorenzo Buscicchi, University of Waikato, Hamilton (New Zealand); https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7851-148X
Abstract
This paper devises the Paradox of Hedonism as the paradox of politically pursuing happiness. The resulting Political Paradox of Happiness is analyzed as an issue for happiness policies. In doing so, the choice of employing an empirical method and of focusing on mental health policies is justified. From the current investigation, it emerges that there is strong evidence confirming that mental health policies are an effective way to purposefully increase the happiness of a collective. Thus, it appears that the political pursuit of happiness is not daunted by its self-defeatingness. Happiness policies, like public policies in general, may have adverse effects but this does not seem to be systematic. Given that the empirical evidence on mental health policies is unambiguous, the Political Paradox of Happiness does not seem to be a valid objection to happiness policies.
Keywords: Happiness; Well-being; Mental Health; Utilitarianism; Paradox of Hedonism.
1. Introduction
The influence of hedonistic utilitarianism in political philosophy and public policy has been important (Driver, 2009). In 1789, Bentham developed a hedonic calculation for policy-makers directed at maximizing pleasure and minimizing pain among people (Bentham, 1789/1970). The hedonistic utilitarian calculation is intended to support policy-makers to determine policies that would generate the greatest happiness. According to hedonistic utilitarianism as a political theory, the right public policy is the one that produces (or is most likely to produce) the greatest net-happiness for all concerned.
Several scholars have questioned the validity of using GDP as an indicator of societal well-being. Therefore, the creation of better indicators of social welfare is a topical debate for policy-makers. These conceptual novelties are now employed in measurements and policy-making (Fleurbaey, 2009). The present research focuses on one of these developments, happiness policies. In 1972, the King of the Buddhist nation of Bhutan, declared Gross National Happiness, instead of Gross Domestic Product, the goal of his policies (Bok, 2010, p. 6). Later, the Stiglitz Commission (2009) declared that research shows that well-being can be meaningfully tracked and that it is desirable for the Government to collect such data. Since then, countries such as Ecuador, France, Italy, New Zealand, Scotland, Sweden, and the United Kingdom have used happiness indices to inform their policies (The Global Happiness Council, 2018). Currently, well-being constitutes (together with health) one of the seventeen sustainable development goals set by the United Nations (UN General Assembly, 2015).[1] Scholars supporting the view that happiness should be the aim of public policy include, among many, Layard (2006), Veenhoven (2010), Oishi and Diener (2014), De Neve and colleagues (2020).
Given the analogies between hedonistic utilitarianism and happiness policies (Lane, 2000; Layard, 2005; Oishi & Diener, 2014; Ryan, 2010; Veenhoven, 2004), it is topical to analyze the objections to this political theory.[2] Veenhoven (2010) divides the objections to hedonistic utilitarianism into moral and pragmatic. Concerning the former, it is sometimes believed that utilitarianism violates principles of justice[3] and that its hedonistic foundations are misplaced because pleasure is not the only valuable good.[4], [5] Concerning the latter, the main pragmatic objection to the theory consists in the claim that happiness cannot be measured. However, in the last decades, we have witnessed a dramatic rise in confidence about the possibility of tracking this feeling. As written by Frey and Stutzer (2009, p. 302), there is now broad scholarly agreement that experienced utility and well-being can be measured with a reasonable degree of accuracy. Scholars that overall defend happiness-measures include, for example, Dolan and Peasgood (2008), Layard (2009), Diener and colleagues (2009), Oishi and Diener (2014), Adler and Seligman (2016), Frijters and colleagues (2020), Helliwell (2021), Layard and De Neve (2023).
The paper is organized in the following way: after having presented the research question and the research methods, the Paradox of Hedonism is outlined, and the Political Paradox of Happiness is introduced. Second, the evidence on mental health policies and thus, generalizing, on happiness policies is analyzed. Finally, it is claimed that the Political Paradox of Happiness is not a damaging obstacle for happiness policies.
2. Research Question and Methodology
Below, an issue with hedonistic utilitarianism that is supposedly a consequence of its hedonistic foundations is addressed. In fact, hedonism is allegedly threatened by its self-defeatingness. According to the Paradox of Hedonism, the pursuit of happiness defeats its aim. What it is called the “Political Paradox of Happiness” consists in the claim that the political pursuit of happiness is self-defeating. Political organizations that subscribe to hedonistic utilitarianism while trying to increase public happiness, would end up diminishing it. So, this is the research question: are happiness policies doomed to fail in making a population happier as a consequence of the Political Paradox of Happiness?
Bentham described the dimensions of value of a pleasure and a pain that need to be taken into consideration when devising a policy. Among them, there is “purity” or “the chance [pleasure] has of not being followed by sensations of the opposite kind” (Bentham, 1789/1970, pp. 38-39). So, it emerges that the hedonic calculation already excludes the possibility of the Political Paradox of Happiness. The value of purity determines that a pleasure is better if it is not followed by pain. The pain following a pleasure (e.g. distressing addiction of the population to a State-provided drug) is already computed in the hedonic calculation. If purity is appropriately weighted in the calculation, the possibility of the Political Paradox of Happiness is theoretically excluded.
Since it seems that we are facing a practical problem, an empirical investigation seems desirable. The empirical investigation of policies based on hedonistic utilitarianism has the limitation that it can evaluate only non-ideal hedonistic utilitarian policies, since an ideal hedonistic utilitarian political organization has never existed. However, the generalizability of the findings to ideal hedonistic utilitarian policies does not seem specifically problematic.
What it is possible to investigate empirically is only a political pursuit of happiness that is not exclusive: policy-makers have never pursued happiness without, at the same time, pursuing different political goals. Yet, since political organizations tend to be axiologically pluralist, this could be said about findings on every kind of policy. The generalizability of the findings on non-ideal hedonistic utilitarian policies to ideal hedonistic utilitarian policies, despite being an assumption, is entitled to the same degree of confidence as, for example, the generalizability of the evidence on GDP-growth to a hypothetical political organization that focuses on economic growth only.
Notice that the possibility of testing empirically armchair speculations such as the Political Paradox of Happiness constitutes a turning point in the history of hedonistic utilitarianism and policymaking. In fact, for long time, the feasibility of the hedonic calculation has been considered a serious problem for the theory (Crimmins, 2015). Unfortunately, every endeavour to reduce policymaking to a straightforward calculation failed because Bentham and his followers were incapable of measuring and comparing the intensity of pleasure and pain experienced by the population. Instead, the number of scientific articles on happiness published each year has been growing at a tremendous rate since the 1970s (Veenhoven, 2009). Today, we possess extensive and fairly reliable scientific insights about happiness, a tendency that seems likely to continue. Thanks to the science of happiness, we may have solved the measurement problems that afflicted classical utilitarianism.
To answer the research question, the focus is on a specific set of policies recommended by the literature on happiness-directed policy-making, mental health policies. Why is such focus on mental health policies adopted? Buettner and colleagues (2020) identify fifty-six strategies that policy-makers can adopt to raise happiness. As pointed out by Frijters and Krekel (2021, pp. 4-6), a happiness-approach to policy-making can be applied to disparate fields; the authors claim that also policy-areas not usually associated with it, such as national defence, could benefit from a happiness-approach. Thus, to do not arbitrary include/exclude policies from the happiness-policies category, the focus is set on a sub-group of policies that surely belong to the group, mental health policies (p. 320).
The evidence on mental health policy is presented through a narrative review. This literature review’s technique—as opposed to a systematic review—cannot remove bias from the literature’s selection process. A legitimate objection to narrative reviews is that they may “cherry pick” evidence to support a particular claim. This constitutes a limitation of the present study. However, the narrow focus and prescribed methods of a systematic review hinder the comprehensive coverage that is required by the present study. In fact, there is not a single research-agenda that answers directly the research question. Therefore, the more flexible narrative literature review is deemed as the best approach to identify different lines of research that might contribute to answering the research-question.
3. Political Paradox of Happiness
a) Paradox of Hedonism
Happiness is like a butterfly which, when pursued, is always beyond our grasp, but, if you will sit down quietly, may alight upon you.
This simile evokes the so-called Paradox of Hedonism. The Paradox of Happiness, the Pleasure Paradox, etc, are other names often employed interchangeably. The Paradox consists in the claim that the pursuit of pleasure is self-defeating. Below, the Paradox of Hedonism only is mentioned, happiness is understood as positive affect, a positive net-sum of pleasant and unpleasant feelings.[6]
Different versions of hedonism have been criticized since antiquity. Meanwhile, philosophers have also considered the Paradox of Hedonism (Buscicchi, 2022b). Especially in pop-culture, this paradox is frequently used to object hedonism. According to the paradox, hedonism is self-defeating: if we pursue pleasure, we are less likely to achieve it. Following this objection, if hedonism is not happiness-producing, a true hedonist should abandon the theory.
Regarding empirical evidence, as reported by Humprey and colleagues (2021) and Zerwas and Ford (2021), different lines of research may seem to confirm the psychological reality of the Paradox. Similarly, in a recent study, Zerwas and colleagues (2024) analysed the relation between a specific aspect of pursuing happiness, monitoring one’s progress toward one’s happiness goal, and happiness. The authors found that monitoring one’s happiness is linked with worse happiness due to negative meta-emotional experiences, supporting the view that pursuing happiness might lead to less of it.
b) Political Paradox
The unintended consequences of intentional social action are debated in the social sciences at least since Merton (1936). Since then, social scientists have collected examples of public policies generating unwelcome side-effects (for example, see: Roots, 2004). The connection between unintended consequences and incompetence is established by several authors (Beahrs, 1992; Rivlin, 1984; Vernon, 1979).[7] Similarly, according to Karapin and Feldman (2016), paradoxical results abound in policy-making due to the complexity of social life and the incalculability of the strategic interactions that can emerge when a Government tries to pursue a goal.
As Eggleston (2013, p. 3794) holds, the (individual) Paradox of Hedonism can be understood as applying to collectives as well. Relatedly, the Political Paradox of Happiness holds that the political attempt to maximize happiness results in less net-happiness. A political organization pursuing happiness brings about less happiness than it would by pursuing some other political goals. According to Layard (2005, p. 133), a prominent scholar in the field, the Political Paradox of Happiness, a consequence of classical utilitarianism’s hedonistic foundations, constitutes a possible problem for happiness policies.[8]
Below, the Political Paradox is understood as a different phenomenon from the mere aggregation of paradoxical effects at the individual level, a possible mechanism that exceeds the scope of the present study. The political pursuit of happiness does not necessarily elicit the individual pursuit and, possibly, the individual paradox. Usually, citizens are not perfectly informed about public policies. Even more, happiness nudges might have weak requirements of transparency (Fabian & Pykett, 2022). Likewise, Diener and colleagues (2009, p. 124) hold that the individual and the political paradoxes do not go necessarily hand in hand when they advance that decision-makers can shape policies not fostering the individual pursuit of happiness.
The Political Paradox of Happiness should also be distinguished from the concern that policy decisions cannot affect well-being. According to it, if well-being is fully determined by inborn genetic factors—Nes (2023) reports that studies have found happiness to be influenced by genes—changing people’s life conditions would not alter their wellbeing. Likewise, if well-being descends only from comparation between individuals’ relative conditions, changes at societal level would not alter the average well-being of a population (Haidt et al., 2008). In other words, if well-being depends entirely on positional goods such as wealth and status, competitors are trapped in a zero-sum game. Regarding this issue, Diener and colleagues (2009, p. 118) claim that, although these concerns are supported by empirical evidence, these effects are not substantial enough to undermine the usefulness of well-being-based policy. Veenhoven (2014) calls “livability theory” the view according to which observed differences in collective happiness are explained by the human needs-environment fit. Similarly, he claims that, if livability theory is wrong, there is no point in seeking to increase the overall happiness. Again, he concludes that, so far, the available evidence supports this theory; therefore, promoting greater happiness remains a legitimate political objective.
Buscicchi (2022b) finds two mechanisms of the Paradox of Hedonism: overly-conscious pursuit of pleasure and the incompetence account. The overly-conscious pursuit of pleasure does not seem to apply to the collective version of the Paradox. The psychological phenomena that might elicit ironic effects, e.g. meta-awareness of pleasure reducing pleasure, do not seem to operate if the pursuer, the political organization, and the experiencer, the individual citizen, are two distinct subjects. Thus, the incompetence account seems the most plausible mechanism behind the Political Paradox of Happiness.[9] As Haybron (2011) claims while speaking of happiness policies, Government interventions may introduce forms of error, and there is ongoing debate over whether such measures are more likely to cause harm than produce benefits.[10]
According to the incompetence account, although we assume we are able to measure happiness, we are still so incompetent in purposely increasing public happiness that if we try we may end up failing dramatically and reducing it. The incompetence account should not be conflated with the issues in measurement downplayed above because, as claimed by Diener and colleagues (2009, pp. 6-7), from happiness measures do not follow the policies that should be adopted. For example, they consider the issue of commuting. Research shows that long commutes are associated with lower well-being. Yet this finding does not provide us with a solution to the issue. Policy-makers can consider different solutions and each of them might generate its own set of problems.
Indeed, the effectiveness of happiness policies is a serious issue. For example, the World Happiness Report 2023 (p. 79) admits that good intentions alone are not enough; many policymakers face capability constraints that prevent success. Similarly, in its 2022 Mental Health and Well-being Plan, the UK Government claimed that there was still the need for better evaluation of happiness-interventions to help shape policy decisions.
c) Is the Paradox Compelling?
As claimed by the scholarship on unintended consequences of intentional social action, political incompetence is not exclusive to the pursuit of happiness. Errors have arisen from the pursuit of GDP-growth too, such as policies directed at economic growth that have in the past turned out to be failures. Thus, what does elicit the intuition that the Political Paradox of Happiness is a more compelling issue than the ironic consequences of policies directed at GDP-growth?
The answer lies in the epistemic problems that descend from affects in general and happiness in particular, as opposed to hard policy-goals such as GDP-growth. Affects and science are often considered juxtaposed (Barbalet, 2002). For long time, affects have been deliberately and methodologically erased from the narrative and practice of science. Affects have historically been considered irrational and too elusive to be objects of knowledge. Nowadays, scientists are sometimes challenging these clichés but the fact that they are clichés implies that they are part of our common sense.
Similarly, in politics, we can observe a tendency to see affects as noise, something to be eliminated. Scholars and media have often portrayed affects as something to be replaced by reason and hard fact (Miller, 2011).[11] Accordingly, a rational public policy would eliminate affective factors, the opposite of making an affect, happiness, its goal.[12]
To recap, when we make policy decisions we pit different goals against one another. Policy-makers might agree that both GDP-growth and happiness are valuable goals. However, resources are limited, setting priorities is inescapable and the tools available to Governments are mainly law and bureaucracy—blunt instruments for such a fragile matter as happiness according to Lane (2000, p. 265). As advanced by Ryan (2010, p. 439), we should pursue concrete political goals—health, social insurance, decent education, low levels of crime—and then perhaps we shall obtain public happiness as a by-product.[13] According to the incompetence account of the Political Paradox of Happiness, if we pursue happiness as a political goal, we have scarce knowledge of it and we obtain less happiness than, for example, by focusing on GDP-growth. Symmetrically, if we focus on a hard goal such as GDP-growth, we obtain indirectly more happiness than by aiming directly at it.[14]
As an example of a counterproductive happiness policy, let’s consider the case of single-mothers, a group that is reported to suffer of a happiness-gap (Ifcher & Zarghamee, 2014). Since employment is associated with higher well-being according to literature and common sense, a benevolent policy-maker might legitimately think that, by supporting single-mothers’ employment, the happiness-gap would be reduced. However, such a policy could form a vicious cycle, reducing single-mothers’ happiness. In fact, it seems that more generous family policies such as paid time-off and child-care subsidies, the opposite of priming single-mothers to work more, might be the best strategy to increase their happiness (Glass et al., 2016).
Given the popularity of happiness among citizens of Western liberal-democracies, and the interest in adopting happiness to direct policy-making, it is important to analyze this objection, the problem of self-defeatingness. Citizens considering the maximization of Gross National Happiness as the goal of public policy would be remiss to support these policies if no defense of their effectiveness is presented. In fact, the idea of collective happiness sometimes elicits pessimism. Thus, it is topical to analyze the Political Paradox of Happiness in order to assess whether this skepticism about the political pursuit of happiness is justified.
4. Mental Health Policies
a) Greatest Happiness through Mental Health
According to Layard (2005, p. 183) mental illness might be the largest cause of unhappiness in the West. As claimed by Bok (2010, p. 124), relieving suffering represents an exceptional opportunity for any Government aiming to improve the happiness of the population and in developed Western societies mental illness seems to be a prime cause of suffering. The focus on these policies does not necessarily rely on a negative utilitarian approach, in which the reduction of suffering is privileged to the promotion of happiness. Even classical utilitarianism, which weighs pleasure and pain equally, might recommend policies that give preference to the least happy people because happiness gains could be easier to achieve by focusing on those that are worst off.
Indeed, Touburg and Veenhoven (2015) checked the prediction that investment in mental health is likely to add to average happiness. They took the data of average happiness in different countries from the World Database of Happiness. Primed with this question, “Taking all together, how satisfied or dissatisfied are you with your life as a whole these days? Please answer with a number between 0 and 10, where 0 stands for most dissatisfied and 10 for most satisfied”, Togo’s citizens replied on average 2,6, Costa Ricans 8,5. Then, Touburg and Veenhoven considered the number of psychiatrists per 100.000 inhabitants (from 0 in some countries, predominantly in Africa, to 25 in Iceland) and the number of psychologists working in mental health per 100.000 inhabitants (from 0 in Cameroon and Angola to 106 in Argentina). Touburg and Veenhoven tracked the share of mental health in the total health budget (from 0%, mainly in Africa, to 13% in Luxembourg). Then, the authors calculated the correlations between these variables. To avoid that economic development could cause a spurious correlation, they considered the relations separately among four different levels of affluence. Based on 143 countries, Touburg and Veenhoven’s analysis showed a strong positive correlation between average happiness and the numbers of psychiatrists/psychologists per capita. This correlation was found to be stronger in developed countries and weaker at intermediate levels of affluence. Another analysis, based on 65 countries, found a positive correlation between a greater share of health budget dedicated to mental health and happiness. The correlation was very strong in the 20 most affluent countries. In these developed countries, the positive association between happiness and share of mental health spending was twice as strong that the association between happiness and the health budget in general. Taking stock, Touburg and Veenhoven’s research, although correlational in nature, seems to point in the direction of a causal effect of mental health care on average happiness.
In addition, it might be wrong to devise mental health policies that address only the clinical population and do not strive for the prevention of mental illnesses in people that do not currently suffer from a mental health disorder. Rather, as claimed by Huppert (2004), it might be sensible to devise policies that aim at shifting the entire collectivity toward better mental health. Similarly, the OECD (2023a) holds that mental health goes beyond a binary distinction mental illness present/absent and that considering positive mental health allows the design of proactive rather than reactive mental health policies.[15] For all these reasons, the conceptual difference between happiness policies and mental health policies seems to vanish. Accordingly, in their systematic review of mental health interventions, Le and colleagues (2021) included both interventions aiming at treating mental illness and interventions aiming at enhancing well-being.
So, according to the Political Paradox of Happiness, the political attempt to increase public happiness, including through mental health policies, is self-defeating: the population would be less happy as a result. This supposed phenomenon, in the most plausible version, can derive from the waste of available resources on ineffective policies. As noticed by Le and colleagues (2021), the amount of resources that is spent on treating mental illness alone is not negligible. In Australia, for example, around 9.9 billion $—7.6% of the health spending—was directed to mental health treatment in 2017 to 2018. By diverting resources from other goals which we know better how to reach such as GDP-growth, we may reduce people’s happiness through taxation and ineffective public-spending.
Obviously, the claim that happiness-directed public policies might backfire does not involve that public policy per se is self-defeating. We know of public policies that were successful. For example, thinking about our recent past, Government interventions were fruitful in suppressing COVID-19 spread and mortality evolution in 2020 (Fernández et al., 2023). It seems superfluous to say that political organizations may be powerful allies in raising public health.
Economic evaluation is increasingly employed for informing health policy. While epidemiology, the cornerstone of public health, deals with identifying risk factors for diseases and targets for preventive interventions, economic evaluation addresses the feasibility, scalability, and sustainability of the interventions. Moreover, cost-effectiveness analysis allows us to evaluate the health-gains in relation to the costs of different interventions. Return on investments analysis consists in quantifying the benefit of an investment in monetary terms so it can be compared with its costs.
Considering the literature on economic evaluation of mental health policies, the worry about them being counter-productive seems unjustified. In 2022, the World Health Organization (p. 100) claimed that there is evidence for interventions that are cost-effective compared to an epidemiological scenario of no-intervention. According to the Global Happiness Policy Report 2018, proper mental health treatments are now available, even if many Governments fail to recognize their advancements. Unfortunately, the report advances, the stigma that surrounds mental illness often causes its absence from political debate despite the huge cost of mental illness for society (in addition to individuals) and the huge benefits that funding mental health services would have (The Global Happiness Council, 2018). As claimed by the Global Happiness Policy Report 2019, in high-income countries, the evidence for the benefits of spending on mental health is “overwhelming” (The Global Council for Happiness and Wellbeing, 2019). Similarly, according to the OECD, there is a “clear case” for investments in mental health and there is “sound and quite extensive evidence” on the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of mental health interventions (McDaid et al., 2017, p. 35).
Focusing on the UK, McDaid and colleagues (2022) advanced the economic case for investing in the prevention of mental health conditions. To this end, they first estimated the costs of mental health conditions: in 2019, they were almost 150 billion $ (roughly 5% of British GDP). Notice that McDaid and colleagues hold this estimate to be highly conservative because it does not include, for example, presenteeism (i.e. being at work but underperforming), absenteeism (i.e. to be on sick leave), sub-threshold conditions, and related physical health problems. Secondly, McDaid and colleagues conducted a review of evidence on interventions and advanced that there are cost-effective actions. Regarding depression, these include: peer-delivered support for mothers and young children, school-delivered initiatives to tackle bullying, cognitive and mindfulness-based therapies for adults. There is also evidence on exercise to prevent depression.[16]
Concerning a recent systematic review, Le and colleagues (2021) reviewed the research on the cost-effectiveness of mental health prevention/promotion interventions. Electronic databases were searched for relevant studies published between 2008 and 2020; 65 studies met the criteria for inclusion. Le and colleagues concluded that most studies consistently found that interventions for mental health prevention and promotion provide value for money compared to no-intervention.
Regarding public finances, Layard (2017) found that the positive fiscal impact of reduced benefits and physical health costs appears to double the cost of the investments on mental health treatments. Layard stresses how mental illness causes an important economic damage because it especially affects people of working age. Citizens with poor mental health are more likely to be unemployed and, if employed, to be on sick leave or being underperforming. For anxiety and depression, especially through cognitive-behavioral therapy, we can treat them with a success rate of 50% or more, with many other patients improving substantially, and the likelihood of relapses halved. Thus, Layard estimates that, for each dollar spent on delivering treatments, roughly double is saved on welfare benefits and on physical health care.
Similarly, the World Health Organization (WHO, 2021a) published a report on the prevention and management of mental health conditions in the Philippines. First, the WHO estimated in 1.37 billion $ per year (0.41% of the GDP) the economic losses caused by mental health conditions in this country. This detriment corresponds to the workdays that are lost (26.3 million for absenteeism and 14.4 million for presenteeism) plus the cost of premature deaths due to poor mental health.
The study included interventions to prevent and/or manage, for example, anxiety, depression, psychosis, bipolar disorder, and alcohol dependence. Let’s focus on interventions directed at treating depression. These interventions included psychosocial treatments (e.g. psychotherapy or psychoeducation) and anti-depressant medications; the estimated costs of delivering these treatments for 10 years within primary care were 2849 million $.
Finally, it was conducted an analysis of return on investment by comparing the impacts on health and productivity with the costs. The analysis found that every dollar invested in interventions targeting depression would bring 5.3 dollars in return over 10 years. These results seem to show that mental health policies are not only effective, but they seem to bring important returns.
With regards to return on investment, Stelmach and colleagues (2022) led an economic modelling study to understand the costs and benefits of interventions to prevent or treat anxiety, depression, bipolar disorder, and suicide among adolescents. They developed a model that followed groups of adolescents (10-19 years old) from 36 countries. Stelmach and colleagues estimated the cost of interventions and modelled their outcomes regarding health, education and employment. They concluded that the interventions at stake bring a return of investment of 23.6 over 80 years. This means that, for 1 dollar invested, we expect 23.6 dollars to be returned to the economy over 80 years. This high return on investments was observed across regions and country income levels. Between the interventions, the highest return on investment emerged from treating mild depression with group-based cognitive-behavioural therapy, prevention of suicide attempts among high-risk adolescents, and universal prevention of combined anxiety and depression in lower-middle income and low-income countries.
Likewise, Jackson-Morris and colleagues (2024) conducted an analysis of return on investment for the prevention and treatment of adolescent mental disorder and suicide in England. They found that a package of interventions (including anxiety prevention, depression prevention, mild-anxiety treatment, mild-depression treatment) had a return of investment 1:15 over 10 years and 1:55 over 80 years. This means that these interventions returned 15 dollars for 1 dollar invested and 55 dollars for 1 dollar invested within a 10-years and an 80-years’ time-horizon. Once again, this study found that the interventions at stake were able to improve adolescents’ mental health while generating economic benefits.
To sum up, the empirical evidence on mental health policies shows that these are not counter-productive. On the contrary, it seems that there is an evidence-to-action gap in implementing and scaling-up evidence-based interventions for improving the population’s mental health. If there is a strategy for increasing a population’s happiness—mental health policy—that is effective and does not backfire, it descends that a happiness-approach to policymaking has at least one effective tool for increasing the happiness of a population without generating paradoxical effects. The research we possess does not give us any legitimate reason to hold that happiness policies are destined to be self-defeating.
Finally, collective decision-making seems to happen, in large part, under a condition of risk and uncertainty. Even assuming an always more reliable happiness-research, its translation into public policy will likely be characterized by complexity. Happiness policies, like every kind of political action, have a political nature that should not be obscured by their scientific aspects (Duncan, 2010).[17] Happiness-research, as with science in general, cannot provide findings that can be translated directly into policies without a public debate about the associated political risk (Duncan, 2007). The World Happiness Report 2022 (p. 71) seems to reach the same conclusion as it alleges that a clear definition and precise measurement of happiness is lacking in guiding policy; instead, the happiness framework must be aligned with societal expectations.
Happiness seems for many a valuable political goal; our limited experience, compared for example with GDP-growth, should not prevent us from pursuing people’s release from suffering. It would be irrational to not implement policies aimed at progress in mental health just because we are more experienced with the denial of their urgency. The negative effects of uncertainty can be mitigated by adopting an approach to decision-making that embraces complexity.[18] Moreover, policies’ implementation would allow us to study their effects, our competence would grow and the probability of the Political Paradox of Happiness would further decrease.
In this paper, an objection, self-defeatingness, that surrounds the political theory of hedonistic utilitarianism and the resulting happiness-policies was refined; a definition of the Political Paradox of Happiness was presented. Then, the employment of empirical evidence was justified by claiming that the Political Paradox of Happiness is more likely a practical problem determined by incompetence. Next, the focus on mental health policies was substantiated and the evidence on them and, generalizing, on happiness policies was analyzed. Thus, it was concluded that the Political Paradox of Happiness is not a damaging issue for a happiness-approach to policymaking.
Ethical statement
The present study did not involve human participants, the collection of personal data, or any intervention. Therefore, ethical approval and informed consent were not required. All sources were appropriately acknowledged and cited in accordance with academic and publication standards.
Data Availability Statement
No original data were generated or collected for this study. The findings are based on previously published literature, with all sources appropriately cited and referenced.
Funding
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
Authors' Contribution
The author was responsible for conceptualization, literature search, methodology, analysis and interpretation of the literature, and writing and revising the manuscript. The author approved the final version of the manuscript.
Use of AI technologies
No artificial intelligence (AI) tools or generative AI technologies were used in the preparation, analysis, or writing of this manuscript.
Acknowledgement
I would like to thank Dr. Dan Weijers and Dr. Ruut Veenhoven for their valuable feedback at various stages of the writing of this paper.
Reference List
Adler, A. & Seligman, M. E. P. (2016). Using wellbeing for public policy: Theory, measurement, and recommendations. International Journal of Wellbeing, 6(1), 1–35. 10.5502/ijw.v6i1.1
Barbalet, J. (2002). Science and emotions. The Sociological Review, 50(2_suppl), 132–150. 10.1111/j.1467-954X.2002.tb03595.x
Beahrs, J. O. (1992). Paradoxical effects in political systems. Political Psychology, 13(4), 755–769. 10.2307/3791500
Bentham, J. (1970). An introduction to the principles of morals and legislation. Clarendon Press. (Original work published 1789). 10.1093/actrade/9780198205166.book.1
Bok, D. (2010). The politics of happiness: What Government can learn from the new research on well-being. Princeton University Press. 10.1515/9781400832194
Buettner, D., et al. (2020). Ways to greater happiness: A delphi study. Journal of Happiness Studies, 21, 2789–2806. 10.1007/s10902-019-00199-3
Buscicchi, L. (2022a). Experience machine. In Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Buscicchi, L. (2022b). Paradox of hedonism. In Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Choi, M., et al. (2022). Do liberals value emotion more than conservatives? Political partisanship and lay beliefs about the functionality of emotion. Motivation and Emotion. 10.1007/s11031-022-09997-4
Crimmins, J. E.. (2015). Jeremy Bentham. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2024 ed.). Stanford University.
De Neve, J. E., et al. (2020). Taking a wellbeing years approach to policy choice. British Medical Journal, 371, m3853. 10.1136/bmj.m3853
Diener, Ed, et al. (2009). Well-being for public policy. Oxford Academic. 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780195334074.001.0001
Dolan, P., & Peasgood, T. (2008). Measuring well‐being for public policy: Preferences or experiences? The Journal of Legal Studies, 37(S2), S5–S31. 10.1086/595676
Driver, J. (2009). The history of utilitarianism. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2014 ed.). Stanford University.
Duncan, G. (2007). After happiness. Journal of Political Ideologies, 12(1), 85–108. 10.1080/13569310601095630
Duncan, G. (2010). Should happiness-maximization be the goal of Government? Journal of Happiness Studies, 11(2), 163–178. 10.1007/s10902-008-9129-y
Eggleston, B. (2013). Paradox of happiness. International Encyclopedia of Ethics (pp. 3794–3799), Wiley-Blackwell. 10.1002/9781444367072.wbiee202
Fabian, M., & Pykett, J. (2022). Be happy: Navigating normative issues in behavioural and well-being public policy. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 17(1), 169–182. 10.1177/1745691620984395
Fernández, D., et al. (2023). Government interventions and control policies to contain the first COVID-19 outbreak: An analysis of evidence. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 51(5), 682–691. 10.1177/14034948231156969
Fleurbaey, M. (2009). Beyond GDP: The quest for a measure of social welfare. Journal of Economic Literature, 47(4), 1029–1075. 10.1257/jel.47.4.1029
Frey, B. S., & Stutzer, A. (2009). Should national happiness be maximized? In A. K. Dutt & B. Radcliff (Eds.), Happiness, Economics and Politics (pp. 301–323), Edward Elgar Publishing. 10.4337/9781849801973.00023
Frijters, P., & Krekel, C. (2021). A handbook for wellbeing policy-making: History, theory, measurement, implementation, and examples. Oxford University Press. 10.1093/oso/9780192896803.001.0001
Frijters, P., et al. (2020). A happy choice: Wellbeing as the goal of Government. Behavioural Public Policy, 4(2), 126–165. 10.1017/bpp.2019.39
Glass, J., et al. (2016). Parenthood and happiness: Effects of work-family reconciliation policies in 22 OECD countries. American Journal of Sociology, 122(3), 886–929. 10.1086/688892
Goodin, R. E. (1995). Utilitarianism as a public philosophy. Cambridge University Press. 10.1017/CBO9780511625053
Haidt, J., et al. (2008). Hive psychology, happiness, and public Policy. The Journal of Legal Studies, 37(S2), S133–S156. 10.1086/529447
Haybron, D. (2011). Happiness. In E. N. Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2020 ed.). Stanford University.
Helliwell, J. F. (2021). Measuring and using happiness to support public policies. In M. T. Lee, L. D. Kubzansky, & J. T. VanderWeele (Eds.), Measuring Well-Being: Interdisciplinary Perspectives from the Social Sciences and the Humanities (pp. 29–49). Oxford University Press. 10.1093/oso/9780197512531.001.0001
Humphrey, A., et al. (2021). When the pursuit of happiness backfires: The role of negative emotion valuation. The Journal of Positive Psychology, 17(5), 611–619. 10.1080/17439760.2021.1897869
Huppert, F. (2004). A population approach to positive psychology: The potential for population interventions to promote well-being and prevent disorder. In P. A. Linley & S. Joseph (Eds.), Positive Psychology in Practice (pp. 693–709), John Wiley & Sons. 10.1002/9780470939338.ch41
Ifcher, J., & Zarghamee, H. (2014). The happiness of single mothers: Evidence from the general social survey. Journal of Happiness Studies, 15, 1219–1238 (2014). 10.1007/s10902-013-9472-5
Jackson S. J., et al. (2022). The wellbeing pandemic: Outline of a contested terrain and a proposed research agenda. Frontiers in Sociology. 10.3389/fsoc.2022.950557
Jackson-Morris, A., et al. (2024). An investment case analysis for the prevention and treatment of adolescent mental disorders and suicide in England. European journal of public health, 34(1), 107–113. 10.1093/eurpub/ckad193
Kahneman, D. (2003). Experienced utility and objective happiness: A moment-based approach', in I. Brocas & J. D. Carrillo (Eds), The Psychology of Economic Decisions: Rationality And Well-Being, Oxford Academic. 10.1093/oso/9780199251063.003.0010
Karapin, R., & Feldman, L. (2016). Unintended consequences. Polity, 48(4), 441–444. 10.1057/s41279-016-0005-5
Lamprianou, I., & Ellinas, A. A. (2019). Emotion, sophistication and political behavior: Evidence from a laboratory experiment. Political Psychology, 40, 859–876. 10.1111/pops.12536
Lane, R. E. (2000). The loss of happiness in market democracies. Yale University Press.
Layard, R. (2005). Happiness: Lessons from a new science. Penguin.
Layard, R. (2006). Happiness and public policy: A challenge to the profession. The Economic Journal, 116, C24-C33. 10.1111/j.1468-0297.2006.01073.x
Layard, R. (2009). Well-being measurement and public policy. In Measuring the Subjective Well-Being of Nations: National Accounts of Time Use and Well-Being (pp. 145–154), National Bureau of Economic Research.
Layard, R. (2017). The economics of mental health. IZA World of Labor, 321. 10.15185/izawol.321
Layard, R., & De Neve, J. E. (2023). What subjective wellbeing is and why it matters. In Wellbeing: Science and Policy (pp. 16–37), Cambridge University Press. 10.1017/9781009298957
Le L. K. D, et al. (2021). Cost-effectiveness evidence of mental health prevention and promotion interventions: A systematic review of economic evaluations. PLoS Medicine, 18(5): e1003606. 10.1371/journal.pmed.10036
McDaid, D., et al. (2017). Understanding effective approaches to promoting mental health and preventing mental illness. OECD Health Working Papers, 97. OECD Publishing. 10.1787/bc364fb2-en.
McDaid, D., et al. (2022). The economic case for investing in the prevention of mental health conditions in the UK. Mental Health Foundation.
Merton, R. K. (1936). The unanticipated consequences of purposive social action. American Sociological Review, 1(6), 894–904.10.2307/2084615
Miller, P. R. (2011). The emotional citizen: Emotion as a function of political sophistication. Political Psychology, 32(4), 575–600. 10.1111/j.1467-9221.2011.00824.x
Nes, R. B. (2023). Happiness and behavior genetics. In F. Maggino, (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Quality of Life and Well-Being Research, Springer. 10.1007/978-3-031-17299-1_4122
Nozick, R. (1974). Anarchy, state, and utopia. Basic Books.
Nussbaum, M. (2013). Political emotions: Why love matters for justice. Harvard University Press. 10.2307/j.ctt6wpqm7
OECD (2023b). How to make societies thrive? Coordinating approaches to promote well-being and mental health. OECD Publishing. 10.1787/fc6b9844-en.
OECD. (2023a). Measuring population mental health. OECD Publishing. 10.1787/5171eef8-en.
Oishi, S., & Diener, E. (2014). Can and should happiness be a policy goal? Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 1(1), 195–203. 10.1177/2372732214548427
Okulicz-Kozaryn, A., et al. (2014). The subjective well-being political paradox: Happy welfare states and unhappy liberals. Journal of Applied Psychology, 99(6), 1300–1308. 10.1037/a0037654
Parfit, D. (1986). Reasons and persons. Oxford University Press. 10.1093/019824908X.001.0001.
Rivlin, A. M. (1984). A public policy paradox. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management, 4(1), 17–22. 10.2307/3323851
Roots, R. I. (2004). When laws backfire: Unintended consequences of public policy. American Behavioral Scientist, 47(11), 1376–1394. 10.1177/0002764204265339
Ryan, A. (2010). Happiness and political theory. Social Research, 77(2), 421–440.
Schlenker, B. R., et al. (2012). Conservatives are happier than liberals, but why? Political ideology, personality, and life satisfaction. Journal of Research in Personality, 46(2), 127–146. 10.1016/j.jrp.2011.12.009.
Singer, P. (1972). Is act-utilitarianism self-defeating? The Philosophical Review, 81(1), 94–104.
Stelmach R., et al. (2022). The global return on investment from preventing and treating adolescent mental disorders and suicide: a modelling study. BMJ Global Health, 7:e007759. 10.1136/ bmjgh-2021-007759
Stiglitz, J., et al. (2009). The measurement of economic performance and social progress revisited: Reflections and overview. Sciences Po publications, 2009-33, Sciences Po.
The Global Council for Happiness and Wellbeing. (2019). Global Happiness and Wellbeing Policy Report 2019. Sustainable Development Solutions Network.
The Global Happiness Council. (2018). Global Happiness Policy Report 2018. Sustainable Development Solutions Network.
Touburg, G., & Veenhoven, R. (2015). Mental health care and average happiness: Strong effect in developed nations. Administration and Policy in Mental Health, 42(4), 394–404. 10.1007/s10488-014-0579-8
UK Department of Health and Social Care. (2022). Mental health and wellbeing plan: Discussion paper and call for evidence. Department of Health and Social Care.
UN General Assembly. (2015). Transforming our world: The 2030 agenda for sustainable development. A/RES/70/1.
UN General Assembly. (2017). Work of the statistical commission pertaining to the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. A/RES/71/313.
Veenhoven, R. (2004). Happiness as a public policy aim: The greatest happiness principle. In P. A. Linley & S. Joseph (Eds.), Positive Psychology in Practice (pp. 658–678), John Wiley. 10.1002/9780470939338.ch39
Veenhoven, R. (2009). World database of happiness: Tool for dealing with the ‘data-deluge’. Psychological Topics, 18, 221–246.
Veenhoven, R. (2010). Greater happiness for a greater number. Journal of Happiness Studies, 11(5), 605–629. 10.1007/s10902-010-9204-z
Veenhoven, R. (2014). Livability theory. In: Michalos, A. C. (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Quality of Life and Well-Being Research (pp. 3645–3647), Springer. 10.1007/978-94-007-0753-5_1669
Veenhoven, R., World Database of Happiness, Erasmus University Rotterdam. https://worlddatabaseofhappiness.eur.nl
Vernon, R. (1979). Unintended consequences. Political Theory, 7(1), 57–73. 10.1177/009059177900700104
White, M. D. (2015). The problems with measuring and using happiness for policy purposes. Mercatus Research, Mercatus Center at George Mason University.
Wolf, S. (1982). Moral saints. The Journal of Philosophy, 79(8), 419–439. 10.2307/2026228
World Happiness Report 2022. (2022). J. F. Helliwell, R. Layard, J. D. Sachs, J.-E. De Neve, L. B. Aknin, & S. Wang. (Eds.). Sustainable Development Solutions Network.
World Happiness Report 2023. (2023). J. F. Helliwell, R. Layard, J. D. Sachs, J.-E. De Neve, L. B. Aknin, & S. Wang. (Eds.). Sustainable Development Solutions Network.
World Health Organization. (2021a). Prevention and management of mental health conditions in the Philippines: The case for investment. World Health Organization.
World Health Organization. (2021b). WHO menu of cost-effective interventions for mental health. World Health Organization.
World Health Organization. (2022). World mental health report: Transforming mental health for all. World Health Organization.
Zerwas, F. K., & Ford, B. Q. (2021). The paradox of pursuing happiness. Current Opinion in Behavioral Sciences, 39, 106–112. 10.1016/j.cobeha.2021.03.006
Zerwas, F. K., et al. (2024). Unpacking the pursuit of happiness: Being concerned about happiness but not aspiring to happiness is linked with negative meta-emotions and worse well-being. Emotion. 10.1037/emo0001381
[1] Targets 3.4 and 3.5 concern the promotion of mental health and the treatment of mental disorders (UN General Assembly, 2017).
[2] According to Lane (2000, p. 264), hedonistic utilitarianism is the political theory grounded in subjective well-being or happiness. The analogy between hedonistic utilitarianism and happiness policies persists even if happiness policies more often employ life-satisfaction, a cognitive evaluation of own’s life, rather than positive affect that tracks more accurately someone’s hedonic state, for measurement.
[3] The utility monster thought experiment, for example, concerns the case in which the dissatisfaction of the many and the satisfaction of the single individual maximize net-happiness (see Nozick, 1974, p. 41).
[4] The experience machine thought experiment, for example, claims that living in touch with reality, in addition to pleasure, contributes to well-being (see Buscicchi, 2022a).
[5] Another common objection is that utilitarianism makes excessive demands on us (see Wolf, 1982). The “too-demanding” objection does not seem relevant here because the present paper addresses hedonistic utilitarianism as a political theory and not as a moral theory. Following Robert Goodin (1995, p. 26), utilitarianism may serve as a useful framework for shaping public policy without necessarily providing an appropriate guide for individual behavior. Impartiality of interests is an utilitarian commitment that may be problematic when dealing with private conduct; on the other hand, this feature seems a necessary condition for a political theory.
[6] For positive affect, see Kahneman (2003).
[7] Following Beahrs (1992) and Rivlin (1984), incompetence might not equal ignorance, in the sense that we might have a lot of knowledge and still be unable to translate it into good decisions.
[8] See, for example, Singer (1972) and Parfit (1986, part 1) for utilitarianism’s self-defeatingness not descending from its hedonistic foundation.
[9] This supports the claim that the Political Paradox of Happiness constitutes a practical problem rather than a theoretical objection for hedonistic utilitarianism. Incompetence is a flaw of the agent applying the theory, not a flaw of the theory.
[10] Similarly, Jackson and colleagues (2022, p. 5) claim that well-being policies will inevitably fail because any endeavour to address well-being is likely to bring about unintended issues.
[11] For example, see: Nussbaum (2013), Lamprianou and Ellinas (2019).
[12] This intuition might be shared especially by conservatives: the stereotypes of “heartless” conservatives and “bleeding hearts” progressives might contain some truth. Researchers, such as Choi and colleagues (2022), have found that progressives see affects as more functional than conservatives. This does not mean that a happiness approach to policy-making necessarily supports progressive policies. Lane (2000), for example, claims that well-being reports are often rightists in their implications. Incidentally, according to Schlenker and colleagues (2012), conservatives might be happier than progressives. Okulicz-Kozaryn and colleagues (2014) employ the expression “subjective well-being political paradox” to describe a phenomenon different than the Political Paradox of Happiness, namely the fact that more progressive countries and more conservative individuals seem to have higher levels of well-being.
[13] Similarly, White (2015, p. 23) holds that policy-makers should promote aggregate well-being by focusing on concrete issues and by leaving the pursuit of happiness to the individuals.
[14] Notice it is not possible for a public policy to pursue happiness directly: there is not such a thing such as a law that can coerce citizens into being happier. So, the political pursuit of happiness is always mediated by an intermediate goal instrumental to happiness. Health is an analogous case: Governments cannot make citizens healthier but can add to public health indirectly by, for example, providing better water quality; all this with undeniable success. Similarly, a happiness-approach to policy-making would serve as a standard to select and evaluate different policy interventions: the political pursuit of happiness can only come with different degrees of indirectness.
[15] The OECD (2023b) also claims that, in addition to the value of positive mental health in itself, well-being is something that other branches of the public sector, beyond health, are more likely to recognize as their goal.
[16] For a list of cost-effective interventions, see also World Health Organization (2021b).
[17] Consider for example, as pointed out by Diener and colleagues (2009), the issue of sustainability: how much weight should we give the well-being of future generations? This is a moral concern, not a scientific one.
[18] See, for example, Frijters and Krekel (2021), Chs. 2, 3.